Examining the Mets’ Offer to Tarik Skubal
I recently wrote an article predicting how much Tarik Skubal would make in free agency. I said “$350 million dollars over eight years which comes out to be $43.75 million dollars a year” which at the time looked like a lot of money. But a report came out on X on Friday that the New York Mets offered Skubal a very very hefty sum of money that exceeded all expectations. Let’s examine it.
On Friday, November 20th, the former GM of the Orioles and Mets posted on X the following:
There has been a constant buzz since Vegas and multiple MLB sources have since confirmed that the initial Mets offer on Tarik Skubal was 9 years almost $400 million. That offer itself would far exceed the total dollars and would be the highest AAV for a free agent SP ever with…
— Jim Duquette (@JimDuquetteGM) November 20, 2026
The Mets’ offer to Tarik Skubal report
“There has been a constant buzz since Vegas and multiple MLB sources have since confirmed that the initial Mets offer on Tarik Skubal was 9 years almost $400 million. That offer itself would far exceed the total dollars and would be the highest AAV for a free agent SP ever with likely other offers to follow. Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander $43.33M are the records currently.”
Wow. I don’t even know where to begin. I guess I’ll start by stating that this guy (like I said before) is a former GM for the Orioles and Mets. He is also a MLB Network Radio voice on Sirius/XM. Contributor on SNY, MASN, MLB Network. Baseball and Media Consultant. Therefore, he is trustworthy adding to the reason why this report is a big shock.
A $400 million-dollar contract would be a crazy record breaker. Not only would the highest AAV ever for a pitcher (Skubal’s contract would be $44.44…million dollars a year), it would also take the number one spot for the most amount of money over any contract. The current record this potential contract could break is Yoshinobu Yamamoto’s $325 million-dollar deal with the Dodgers.
The part that could perhaps be even crazier is that that must be just an initial offer. It’s very unlikely they are deep into negotiations so the contract is likely to keep rising. Especially since Skubal has big markets coming after him such as the obvious Mets, but also the Dodgers, Yankees, Padres, Phillies and maybe even Cubs and Blue Jays interested. If you want to get crazy, throw in a really really big sleeper team like the Cardinals or White Sox (who both need pitching). Those teams are likely to drive the price up significantly possibly even starting a bidding war.
However, there comes a buyer beware as this guy pointed out replying to the rumor:
Because the Mets throwing money at guys has clearly worked out for them
— Erick (@EKlambara) November 20, 2026
The reply to the Mets’ offer to Tarik Skubal report
“Because the Mets throwing money at guys has clearly worked out for them.”
Of course, he means it sarcastically. The Mets have three main contracts that are not working out very well for them. Juan Soto (although he had a better year in 2026), Francisco Lindor, and Bo Bichette. The total cash on those contracts adds up to over $1 billion dollars. With that much money, you would expect a trio of top-tier, elite superstars. But instead, with the Mets, you have plays like this happening all regular season long. While their owner Steve Cohen might be rich, he doesn’t have the best reputation of managing his money.
Soto was good in 2026 but still not where you wanted him to be. Lindor was battling a load of injuries which capped his season. And Bichette didn’t even achieve a WAR above 1.0. Even if the Mets acquire Skubal in free agency, there is a not-so-small chance he flops and becomes their latest overpay while his performance drops off. I think that is what a lot of other fans including me would like to see.
Finally, this is all based on a few ifs. If the report is accurate, and if this report isn’t just put forth by Tarik’s agency to materialize a market, and if he passes the medical, and if the Mets don’t back out. However, if all those small ifs fall into place, Skubal might have his hands on what might just be the most record-breaking contract for a pitcher in MLB history.
Thanks for reading!